N.B: Another guest post today, and one about which I've been quite excited for some time. When not contributing realness to FreeDarko, the Dr. Lawyer Indian Chief is likely found listening to rap music. In an effort to help close out the decade, I asked him for his favorite records since 2000. In response, I got this stunning repudiation of so many things which comprise the contemporary hip-hop landscape. Please enjoy. This is ill.A while back Joey asked me for my top ten albums of the century, and I could only come up with 5/6:1. Ghostface – Supreme Clientele2. Prodigy – Return of the Mac3. MF Doom – Operation Doomsday4. Dr. Dre – 2001*5. Sacred Hoop – Sleep Over
Honorable mention: El-P Fantastic Damage*Note, I almost forgot about this album until my friend, Andy, reminded me.Given the difficulty I had in coming up with even five, I thought it would be fun to write an article about the wackness of current hip-hop that makes a bunch of overgeneralizations and fails to name names in certain cases where it wouldn’t be politically beneficial to do so. I could give a million disclaimers, but instead I’ll give just one: You will not meet a bigger rap fan than me, and that is why I feel so strongly about this shit. Without further adieu...Why Hip-Hop Sucks in 2009. Six Reasons:1) White girls are the new black malesTo the extent that rap has certain qualities of a religion, the standard vision of what God looks like is probably something along the lines of Daryl “DMC” McDaniels circa coke: Some idealized big guy in the clouds wearing Cazals, gold chains, Kangols, Adidas...you know, whatever your parents think of “rappers” being. For years this meant that for up-and-coming rappers, validation was sought from black guys, the physical manifestation of “cred.” This is especially pertinent in the case of white rappers, who required some sort of “I have black friends too” posse to garner any respect (think: back-up dancers in Vanilla Ice/Marky Mark videos all the way up to Dre putting the stamp of approval on Eminem). But black rappers themselves have been no different. Accruing props from some major black figurehead (be it Russell Simmons, Sway and Tech, or Grandmaster X Y Z--fill in the blank with your favorite ‘old school’ prove-you-were-there personage) was pretty much the endgame for pretty much all beginning rappers. And good rap, at least through the later part of the 1990s, was typically geared toward, at bare minimum, gaining the respect of that hyper-masculinized, cartoonishly aggressive, Zulu-endorsed black “figure” in the sky. Regardless of whether that method of attaining cred is disgusting or not, it was essentially standard practice, until the past few years.That black male figurehead has been replaced by a white woman. Jim Jones would rather have Cory Kennedy on his jock than Chuck D at this point. Not exactly sure why this is (is it simple economics that white girls drive the market-->get white dudes to buy stuff/white people = 80% of America = buying public?), but it is. This whole steez has led to pointless Feist-sampling/MIA-jocking/Lady GaGa-collab’ing/KANYE STATING THAT HE KNOWS WHO PETER BJORN AND JOHN AND ANIMAL COLLECTIVE IS SO THAT HIPSTERS ARE LIKE WOW THAT IS SO SURPRISING and other nonsense that has generally resulted in music that sounds like the opposite of The Infamous or Livin’ Proof. Aside from the Lykke Li/Drake collab, which I really dug, rappers’ pursuit of validation of white women has created this super-faux “Pitchfork Media got Pharoahe Monch to play so it’s like the Roxy with Talking Heads and Afrika Bambattaa and Debbie Harry” in one room. Except it isn’t. It fucking sucks. 2) SoulquarianismI’m gonna say something sacrilegious here. Jay Dee contributed to the erosion of good rap. Let me say up front: I really like Jay Dee...just not as much as Skeff Anslem, Large Pro, Premier, Pete Rock, Erick Sermon, Havoc, QDIII, etc. Now, I’d like you to do me a favor and take out your CD collection and start playing the classics. Can you hear the difference between Buhloone Mind State and Stakes Is High? Between Midnight Marauders and Beats, Rhymes, and Life? Between Resurrection/One Day It Will All Make Sense and Like Water for Chocolate? Bizarre Ride II the Pharcyde and Labcabincalifornia? The difference in sonics you hear in each of these cases can be summed up in a word, “rawness.” Note, these are all good albums, but those in the former group are all time classics, and those in the latter group simply don’t rate in that category. The stank flute from “Pack the Pipe,” the Chicago despair of “Hungry,” the downright spookiness of “8 Million Stories.” By 1996, those type of songs were gone, replaced with Jay Dee’s brand of boom-bap neo-soul. I can’t put this all on Jay Dee, though. “F*ck the Police” is one of my favorite beats ever. Jay Dee is simply an illustrative example of how rap began to soften up. Nothing better encapsulates the de-raw-ification of rap than what happened to the Roots following Illadelph Halflife. First of all, ?uestlove turned into some cult-leaderish untrustworthy tastemaker converting his weird trustafarian/Nuyorican army to worship the Sweet-and-lo/Native Tonguian stylings of Little Brother and crap neo-soul like Floetry. Then, his band started sucking, too. Less Malik B and less Hub meant more stringy-soft backgrounds, more hot-air braggadocio from Black Thought, a slew of indistinguishable songs about rap, Philly, Philly rap, hip-hop, love-lyfe, etc. I seriously feel like the Roots let us down. Because of the live-band gimmick, they were our best opportunity to solidify 1994-caliber rap into the mainstream forever. Instead, they became hip-hop Phish, and ?uestlove whined a lot (comprising, in many ways, the predecessor to Kanye). I remember a few years ago talking to the editor-in-chief of a very popular music magazine, and he told me how ?uestlove was hating on their rag for only covering super-mainstream artists or super-underground artists. Ironically, that perfectly exemplifies the route that the Roots dug themselves into: middle. of. the. road. 3) Stupidity is rewardedI made this list in a rather arbitrary fashion, but this is probably reason #1. To sum it up in a sentence: White music is generally rewarded the smarter it is, black music is generally rewarded the dumber it is. The hipster media loves to tout black artists like OJ Da Juiceman, Max B, Young Jeezy, and (gulp) Soulja Boy* while simultaneously engaging in ancestor worship toward Animal Collective, Radiohead, and Arcade Fire. This phenomenon is well-documented, though it is commonly misattributed to hipster obsession with irony (and liking dumb hawdcore crunktastic music = irony in this case). I think it goes beyond irony though, because if you ask any of these cheerleaders to say why they like that type of music, they will give you a very clear response that will commonly include something about swag, presence, charisma, or braggadocio. These are codewords; I’ll let you fill in the rest....To use a movie metaphor, you can think about OJ Da Juiceman et al. as Old School and Wedding Crashers, while AnCo and the like are Brokeback Mountain, Atonement, and The Queen. Both get love from the critics, but at the end of the day, which camp is getting invited to the Oscars?
*Yes, these rappers are stupid. Stupid compared to people like Willie the Kid, La the Darkman, Labtekwon, Smitty, and Foul Mouth Cringe, folks who I think are a tad too smart or subtle to get the type of blog-love that OJ gets. 4) The Michael Moore-ification of political rapHere’s an interesting experiment: Pull out your Ice Cube and Paris albums from the Bush I presidency and listen to their anti-prez raps. Shit makes waaaaaaaaaaaaaay more sense and is oddly far more topical than any political rap produced in the past ten years. Putting the strange new Obama-era aside for a moment, let’s focus on Bush II era political rap, one of the greatest creative letdowns of our time. I remember reading some article in URB magazine right after 9/11 about how the fuckedupedness of the time would spur a renaissance in political rap. Never happened. Instead groups like dead prez et al. made the hip-hop equivalent of Farenheit 9-11, conspiratorial, jumbled oversimplification with an easily digestible “Fuck Bush” tagline.
Seriously, the W presidency served this shit up for you guys on a platter and you couldn’t even bunt (killing these mixed metaphors). Jay-Z and Mos Def both put together some lazy Hurricane Katrina joints. Nas’s Fox News blowup was cool. The Coup did their thing with “Baby let’s have a Baby....” (Boots, we need you!). Jadakiss’s “Why” had some lines. But did we get a definitive take on Iraq or, better yet, a narrative of the young lower-to-middle-class members of hip-hop’s core audience fighting over there? If KRS-One wasn’t in space right now, he would be killing shit.5) Jay-Z and Nas’s snoozing lowered everyone’s GOAT standardsJay and Nas. Great guys. But it still stuns me how anyone who got started listening to Reasonable Doubt and Illmatic can still proclaim these guys co-GOATs or anything near that caliber. These guys are in the same phase of their careers as Iverson, Garnett, Duncan. The impact they had when they first came into the league just puts their present work to shame.
That’s not really the point though. The point is that Jay and Nas became de facto kingz after Biggie died for no real reason other than there was a throne to fill. This was also during the point in their careers that they both started snoozing hard. And now (because Andre 3000 is stingy and strange and likes to sing too much) we’ve lowered our standards for what the GOAT is really all about. As someone who admittedly got into rap in 1991 and *just* missed out on “88” (i.e. the period that “88” symbolized), it shocks me to think of a time when Slick Rick, Big Daddy Kane, Rakim, Kool G Rap, Chuck D, LL Cool J, and KRS-One were all at the top of their game simultaneously. Now those are names worth arguing over. These days we can’t accept an empty throne, so we have been stepping over each for the past few years trying to give the “crown” to people like Cam’ron, the Game, and Weezy. And seriously, I love Lil’ Wayne, but I once tried to tally the number of instances on The Carter III where dude makes an “I’m the shit”/actual pooping pun, and I lost track. The guy is great, Top 30 all time, sure. But, like I said, let’s have some standards.6) Lack of samplesI guess it’s because I stopped listening to West Coast underground stuff that I only noticed this last week while listening to the new Jay-Z “D.O.A.” and the new Mos Def album, but where the hell have the samples gone? Swizz Beats really destroyed that whole era, didn’t he? Did the shit just become too expensive? I suppose Kanye has done his part to bring it back, but he went too hard with the chipmunk stuff, and now it’s kind of back to glossy shit on the radio.
Labels: A Tribe Called Quest, Dr. Dre, FreeDarko, Ghostface Killah, Guest Post, Hip-Hop, Ice Cube, Internets, Jay Dee, Jay-Z, MF Doom, Nas, Prodigy, Rap Critics Suck, The Roots